Discussion about this post

User's avatar
George S. Bardmesser's avatar

One minor technical point: ATACMS range is 300 km, not 165 km. The earliest versions, produced in the 1990s (Block I), had the range of 165 km, but that's old news by now. Block I missiles are also at the end of their shelf life at this point in time. Current ATACMS versions are 300 km.

***

On a different note, the idea that China is planning to invade in 2027 is, in my opinion, a psyop. First, I don't believe that something like this would be leaked by China inadvertently - any such "leak" is a deliberate disinformation. If China says 2027, then the real date (to the extent there is a specific real date) is something other than 2027. Since it presumably isn't 2026, it must be after 2027, when everyone breathes a sigh of relief on December 31, 2027, and says "Okey dokey then, we're safe, no invasion."

In my dilettante's view, China is not capable of a SUCCESSFUL seaborne invasion. First, there are only two successful examples of major seaborne invasions in the entire human history: D-day in 1944, and Okinawa in 1945. Both were across essentially uncontested waters, by armies that had years of combat experience, onto landing grounds conducive to such things. China's military has zero combat experience, the Taiwan Strait will be very much contested, and Taiwan's coast has virtually no beaches where an invading force can land.

Could Xi Jinping order it anyway? Anything is possible, but (again, in my dilettante's view) it is doomed to failure AND to a huge loss of face. The risk of the latter is another constraining factor.

One cautionary note: We think of the future invasion of Taiwan as a sort of "D-Day with Chinese characteristics", just using technology of the 2020s. But China's plan will no doubt rely to a much greater extent on pre-positioned special forces teams already on the island striking key targets and causing general chaos, as well as the local Fifth Column (the KMT) loudly calling for immediate capitulation.

Food for thought.

Ian Van Oene's avatar

It’s been more than 80 years since a large scale opposed landing has happened. No one knows how precision weapons affect it. No one has the tested doctrine to attack or defend. It’s not just himars. It’s javelin and TOW. Hitting landing craft at 2-3 km. No one knows what happens.

9 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?