You're quite right that we are nowhere near understanding how to implement Asimov's Three Laws.
But it's also worth noting that nearly all of Asimov's robot stories were little puzzle pieces that show how inadequate the Three Laws are in the first place. The robot that walks in an endless circle around its slightly radioactive goal because that radius equalizes the impetus of following orders (the second law) with that of self-preservation (the third law). The robot that lies on the witness stand because the testimony he would give would harm somebody. The robot that breaks a spaceship because it was told to grasp a control bar and apply firm pressure (but how firm is "firm"?).
Asimov loved puzzle stories and the Three Laws gave him great scope for play. But even if we knew how to do it with current AI training, it would be far from a panacea.
Oh, yeah. Love Daneel but zeroth scared the crap out of me.
In Eliezer Yudkowsky's early writing about alignment he advocated something he called the Coherent Extrapolated Volition:
"Our coherent extrapolated volition is our wish if we knew more, thought faster, were more the people we wished we were, had grown up farther together; where the extrapolation converges rather than diverges, where our wishes cohere rather than interfere; extrapolated as we wish that extrapolated, interpreted as we wish that interpreted."
The idea is that not only do we want AI to do what we say, we want an aligned AI to not freeze us into twentieth (or now, twenty-first) century values: we have grown a lot in the last few millennia and for us to stop growing because we happen to develop AI would be almost as bad as AI wiping us out. It sounds grand, but since then I think he has walked that back a bit, perhaps because like the three laws it seems unattainable, perhaps because it's bad press if it means compromising with the values of the Chicoms or the Islamists, or (I hope) because he's come to see that the whole idea is as incoherent as the idea of the "common will" that caused so much trouble in the French Revolution.
Yes to all of that. And of course, Daneel represents C.S. Lewis's dictum that a "tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive." I doubt Asimov realized that. Nevertheless, what could be more oppressive than eliminating the possibility of free will? That's the entire purpose of psychohistory, which we eventually learn was Daneel's idea more than Seldon's, and certainly of Galaxia. But it begins with Giskard's destruction of the Earth (or at least allowing Mandamus to destroy it).
Sounds pretty coercive to me! Totalitarian even. We won't rule you: we'll just shape all of history so that you're unknowing passengers on our ship.
The reader can cheer this, despite the tragedy, because we know the Spacer worlds are receding and the Settler worlds are the future. But would either of those things necessarily have been true, and why was that the right outcome? Likewise, was reducing the Interregnum to 1,000 years actually the right call? And why does Hari Seldon get to make that call for everyone else? What if the galaxy would have been better served by Westphalian nation-states for 30,000 years? It's not like the Empire was free.
And Galaxia is basically a smiley face version of the Borg.
Okay, enough geeking out. You have pinpointed my exact issue with AI. It's not that it will become sentient: it won't. But it will get better and better at following instructions, in a manner that will become hard if not impossible to control, especially as it gets better at writing its own.
In certain respects, it would be safer to deal with an actually sentient AI: at least in theory it could be reasoned with. How do you reason with something that relentlessly pursues the logical outcome of its instruction set and the conclusions it draws from them, but without actual reasoning?
It is good that science fiction has been dealing with these issues for decades. We're going to need to think ever more deeply about them as this progresses.
But the only way to defeat this sort of thing is competition. Stifling progress will mean Chinese AI will make those choices. And while Data beat the Borg, a bit stronger Daneel might very well have stopped Giskard.
👏👏👏 A robust and lively discussion on the future of AI in this country with Dr. Martin and Frank Gaffney on Securing America! AI is not the monster it’s made out to be. It will never gain sentience! It can look like it, but it can never actually do it. It will only seek to follow our instructions to the best of its ability. It will never come to life one day, enslave us and takeover the world! This isn’t a Sci Fi movie! Just like your toaster doesn’t come to life and arm itself, your house’s air conditioning system doesn’t come to life and kill you in your sleep and your radio doesn’t come to life and start singing 1950s crooner tunes to you! AI has potential dangers just like any other technology does. Which can be mitigated through regulation and innovation. Just like fossil fuels cause pollution, so we have laws like the Clean Air Act and figured out ways to filter the pollutants out of them. The fear mongering on AI should be ignored just like the fear mongering about COVID and Climate Change. The latter didn’t turn out to be true or accurate and this won’t be either. AI will be a boon to humanity not a detriment! We defintely need to stop Big AI from cornering the market so let’s incentivize competition!
You’re right, Dr. Martin, there will always be a tomorrow. The great AI race with China will be never ending. We’ve got to make sure we stay ahead of them at all times. Nor should we share anything about what we are doing with AI with them. They have proven for decades they are not to be trusted! It’s because the international community has been so trusting toward them that we’re in this situation towards them in the first place. The United States under Ford, Carter, Reagan, Bush I, Clinton, Bush II, Obama, and Biden coddled China in every way. Not Donald Trump, he knows how dangerous they are and he’s taking steps to cause the collapse of the CCP. He’s kicking them out of the Panama Canal, using the Donroe Doctrine to keep them out of the Western Hemisphere, locked them out of Greenland with the recent Tripartite Pact, armed Taiwan, pushed Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and The Philippines to rearm, stop them from ripping us on trade with his tariffs and the trade war, and took out their shadow oil trade. Not to mention dispatching with Maduro and dealing heavy damage to Iran.
Another thing that this issue makes me think about is, the lack of nuance used when discussing it or any hot button issue for that matter. Nuance is something we desperately miss in politics these days. Allow me to provide some examples. I’m a supporter of environmentalism and animal rights but I despise the Vegan Movement and the Animal Rights Movement because of their extremism. I support the United States being a part of NATO and the alliance itself. But I also think the other NATO members need to start paying into it and be partners not dependents. I believe in doing détente with Russia and China and doing arms control agreements with them. But I also believe we should only do so while at the same containing their influence and rolling it back wherever possible like President Trump is currently doing. I’m against the weaponization of space but I support the Golden Dome. I was not a fan of President Trump’s recent speech at the UN, but I also think the UN is a largely toothless and useless institution that needs reform. I would have no problem with Alberta and Saskatchewan become states in the union but I would oppose Washington D.C. and Puerto Rico doing so because it would upset the political balance of power in this country whereas the former would not. I’m all for the government fighting, investigating and prosecuting racism, discrimination and land theft against Native Americans but I also believe we should abolish the Bureau of Indian Affairs, encourage Native people to assimilate and modernize while preserving their culture, teach them to be capitalists, teach them patriotism and empowerment, and make welfare subsidies to Native peoples temporary. I detest white supremacists and Neo-Nazis but I don’t believe in hate speech laws. I don’t like Marine Le Pen but I’m not a fan of Jean-Luc Melechon either.
Let’s say I’m living in the United States in the 1930s. I would be frustrated with the Hoover administration handling the Depression so badly, be appalled by how Hoover and General MacArthur treated the Bonus Marchers, voted for FDR in 1932 and 1936, be a staunch New Dealer all the way, help Americans who were out of work or who were fleeing the Dust Bowl, applaud the Social Security Act, join the Civilian Conservation Corps, applaud the creation of the Tennessee Valley Authority, enjoy the swing music, radio programs, and classic films of the decade like The Wizard of Oz, It Happened One Night, King Kong, Duck Soup, Frankenstein, The Public Enemy, and My Man Godfrey, celebrate the end of Prohibition, cheer Joe Louis knocking out Max Schmeling, go to see Snow White and the Seven Dwarves at the Theater and admire the cartoonist Walt Disney who made it, enjoy reading The Grapes of Wrath, Of Mice and Men, Their Eyes Were Watching God, Brave New World, It Can’t Happen Here, The Hobbit, and Murder on the Orient Express, and be a fan of Laurel & Hardy. At the same time, I would criticize FDR for the Agricultural Adjustment Act, the Court Packing Plan and not backing anti-lynching legislation, be alarmed by the rise of the Communist Party and the German-American Bund, fight against racism and antisemitism in America, stand up for racial, religious and ethnic minorities, call for the U.S. to let in as many Jewish refugees from Europe as possible, denounce Adolf Hitler in Germany and Benito Mussolini in Italy as madmen, call out Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy and Nationalist Japan’s aggression on the international stage, urge the United States to enter World War II to help the Allies, oppose the Anschluss, be disgusted by the Munich Agreement, be disgusted by the persecution of the Jews in Germany, and call for the United States to do a massive military buildup to prepare ourselves for the day we inevitably would have to join the war.
Let’s say I’m living in Hungary in the 1930s and 1940s. I would be a proud Hungarian, proudly wave the Hungarian flag, love traditional Hungarian folk music and folk dances, revere Hungarian nation heroes like Saint Stephen, John Hunyadi, Matthias Corvinus, Francis II, and Lajos Kossuth, enjoy traditional Hungarian dishes like Goulash, Chicken Paprikash, Fisherman’s Soup, and Pörkölt, be a pious member of the Catholic Church, visit Budapest with great reverence and awe, help poor, unemployed and sick Hungarians during the Great Depression, and be furious about the Treaty of Trianon which took away two-thirds of Hungary’s land. At the same time, I would oppose the regime of Admiral Miklós Horthy, oppose Hungary trading with Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy, oppose the anti-Jewish laws passed by the government, be appalled by the discrimination faced by my Jewish neighbors, oppose Hungary joining the Axis Powers, oppose Hungarian troops being sent to assist Nazi Germany on the Eastern Front, oppose the Holocaust in Hungary, assist Hungarian Jews in escaping to safety, would fight against the German occupation of my country, oppose the puppet regime of Ferenc Szálasi and the Arrow Cross Party, protest the Soviet occupation, and would fight for a liberal democracy in Hungary.
Let’s say I’m living in Greece in the 1930s and 1940s. I would be a patriotic Greek, be proud of Ancient Greece and the fact that my country was the one that invented democracy, mathematics, theater, and the Olympic Games, wave the Greek flag with much pride, celebrate Independence Day, admire Alexander the Great’s conquests, admire Aristotle, Archimedes, Socrates, Plato, Pericles, Herodotus, Theódoros Kolokotrónis, and Georgios Karaiskakis, would love eating Moussaka, Gyros, Greek Salad, and Baklavas, love attending big Greek weddings, and would enjoy dancing the Kalamatianos. At the same time, I would be sad to see the fall of the Second Hellenic Republic, oppose the rule of King George II and Ioannis Metaxas, join the resistance movement and fight the Italian, German and Bulgarian invasions, oppose the Holocaust in Greece, help Greek Jews get out of the country, welcome the American, British and Commonwealth forces that liberated my country, and fight to restore democracy in my country after the war was over.
You're quite right that we are nowhere near understanding how to implement Asimov's Three Laws.
But it's also worth noting that nearly all of Asimov's robot stories were little puzzle pieces that show how inadequate the Three Laws are in the first place. The robot that walks in an endless circle around its slightly radioactive goal because that radius equalizes the impetus of following orders (the second law) with that of self-preservation (the third law). The robot that lies on the witness stand because the testimony he would give would harm somebody. The robot that breaks a spaceship because it was told to grasp a control bar and apply firm pressure (but how firm is "firm"?).
Asimov loved puzzle stories and the Three Laws gave him great scope for play. But even if we knew how to do it with current AI training, it would be far from a panacea.
Quite right. And of course the best (or worst) of these was Daneel and the 0th Law.
Oh, yeah. Love Daneel but zeroth scared the crap out of me.
In Eliezer Yudkowsky's early writing about alignment he advocated something he called the Coherent Extrapolated Volition:
"Our coherent extrapolated volition is our wish if we knew more, thought faster, were more the people we wished we were, had grown up farther together; where the extrapolation converges rather than diverges, where our wishes cohere rather than interfere; extrapolated as we wish that extrapolated, interpreted as we wish that interpreted."
The idea is that not only do we want AI to do what we say, we want an aligned AI to not freeze us into twentieth (or now, twenty-first) century values: we have grown a lot in the last few millennia and for us to stop growing because we happen to develop AI would be almost as bad as AI wiping us out. It sounds grand, but since then I think he has walked that back a bit, perhaps because like the three laws it seems unattainable, perhaps because it's bad press if it means compromising with the values of the Chicoms or the Islamists, or (I hope) because he's come to see that the whole idea is as incoherent as the idea of the "common will" that caused so much trouble in the French Revolution.
Yes to all of that. And of course, Daneel represents C.S. Lewis's dictum that a "tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive." I doubt Asimov realized that. Nevertheless, what could be more oppressive than eliminating the possibility of free will? That's the entire purpose of psychohistory, which we eventually learn was Daneel's idea more than Seldon's, and certainly of Galaxia. But it begins with Giskard's destruction of the Earth (or at least allowing Mandamus to destroy it).
Sounds pretty coercive to me! Totalitarian even. We won't rule you: we'll just shape all of history so that you're unknowing passengers on our ship.
The reader can cheer this, despite the tragedy, because we know the Spacer worlds are receding and the Settler worlds are the future. But would either of those things necessarily have been true, and why was that the right outcome? Likewise, was reducing the Interregnum to 1,000 years actually the right call? And why does Hari Seldon get to make that call for everyone else? What if the galaxy would have been better served by Westphalian nation-states for 30,000 years? It's not like the Empire was free.
And Galaxia is basically a smiley face version of the Borg.
Okay, enough geeking out. You have pinpointed my exact issue with AI. It's not that it will become sentient: it won't. But it will get better and better at following instructions, in a manner that will become hard if not impossible to control, especially as it gets better at writing its own.
In certain respects, it would be safer to deal with an actually sentient AI: at least in theory it could be reasoned with. How do you reason with something that relentlessly pursues the logical outcome of its instruction set and the conclusions it draws from them, but without actual reasoning?
It is good that science fiction has been dealing with these issues for decades. We're going to need to think ever more deeply about them as this progresses.
But the only way to defeat this sort of thing is competition. Stifling progress will mean Chinese AI will make those choices. And while Data beat the Borg, a bit stronger Daneel might very well have stopped Giskard.
👏👏👏 A robust and lively discussion on the future of AI in this country with Dr. Martin and Frank Gaffney on Securing America! AI is not the monster it’s made out to be. It will never gain sentience! It can look like it, but it can never actually do it. It will only seek to follow our instructions to the best of its ability. It will never come to life one day, enslave us and takeover the world! This isn’t a Sci Fi movie! Just like your toaster doesn’t come to life and arm itself, your house’s air conditioning system doesn’t come to life and kill you in your sleep and your radio doesn’t come to life and start singing 1950s crooner tunes to you! AI has potential dangers just like any other technology does. Which can be mitigated through regulation and innovation. Just like fossil fuels cause pollution, so we have laws like the Clean Air Act and figured out ways to filter the pollutants out of them. The fear mongering on AI should be ignored just like the fear mongering about COVID and Climate Change. The latter didn’t turn out to be true or accurate and this won’t be either. AI will be a boon to humanity not a detriment! We defintely need to stop Big AI from cornering the market so let’s incentivize competition!
You’re right, Dr. Martin, there will always be a tomorrow. The great AI race with China will be never ending. We’ve got to make sure we stay ahead of them at all times. Nor should we share anything about what we are doing with AI with them. They have proven for decades they are not to be trusted! It’s because the international community has been so trusting toward them that we’re in this situation towards them in the first place. The United States under Ford, Carter, Reagan, Bush I, Clinton, Bush II, Obama, and Biden coddled China in every way. Not Donald Trump, he knows how dangerous they are and he’s taking steps to cause the collapse of the CCP. He’s kicking them out of the Panama Canal, using the Donroe Doctrine to keep them out of the Western Hemisphere, locked them out of Greenland with the recent Tripartite Pact, armed Taiwan, pushed Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and The Philippines to rearm, stop them from ripping us on trade with his tariffs and the trade war, and took out their shadow oil trade. Not to mention dispatching with Maduro and dealing heavy damage to Iran.
Another thing that this issue makes me think about is, the lack of nuance used when discussing it or any hot button issue for that matter. Nuance is something we desperately miss in politics these days. Allow me to provide some examples. I’m a supporter of environmentalism and animal rights but I despise the Vegan Movement and the Animal Rights Movement because of their extremism. I support the United States being a part of NATO and the alliance itself. But I also think the other NATO members need to start paying into it and be partners not dependents. I believe in doing détente with Russia and China and doing arms control agreements with them. But I also believe we should only do so while at the same containing their influence and rolling it back wherever possible like President Trump is currently doing. I’m against the weaponization of space but I support the Golden Dome. I was not a fan of President Trump’s recent speech at the UN, but I also think the UN is a largely toothless and useless institution that needs reform. I would have no problem with Alberta and Saskatchewan become states in the union but I would oppose Washington D.C. and Puerto Rico doing so because it would upset the political balance of power in this country whereas the former would not. I’m all for the government fighting, investigating and prosecuting racism, discrimination and land theft against Native Americans but I also believe we should abolish the Bureau of Indian Affairs, encourage Native people to assimilate and modernize while preserving their culture, teach them to be capitalists, teach them patriotism and empowerment, and make welfare subsidies to Native peoples temporary. I detest white supremacists and Neo-Nazis but I don’t believe in hate speech laws. I don’t like Marine Le Pen but I’m not a fan of Jean-Luc Melechon either.
Let’s say I’m living in the United States in the 1930s. I would be frustrated with the Hoover administration handling the Depression so badly, be appalled by how Hoover and General MacArthur treated the Bonus Marchers, voted for FDR in 1932 and 1936, be a staunch New Dealer all the way, help Americans who were out of work or who were fleeing the Dust Bowl, applaud the Social Security Act, join the Civilian Conservation Corps, applaud the creation of the Tennessee Valley Authority, enjoy the swing music, radio programs, and classic films of the decade like The Wizard of Oz, It Happened One Night, King Kong, Duck Soup, Frankenstein, The Public Enemy, and My Man Godfrey, celebrate the end of Prohibition, cheer Joe Louis knocking out Max Schmeling, go to see Snow White and the Seven Dwarves at the Theater and admire the cartoonist Walt Disney who made it, enjoy reading The Grapes of Wrath, Of Mice and Men, Their Eyes Were Watching God, Brave New World, It Can’t Happen Here, The Hobbit, and Murder on the Orient Express, and be a fan of Laurel & Hardy. At the same time, I would criticize FDR for the Agricultural Adjustment Act, the Court Packing Plan and not backing anti-lynching legislation, be alarmed by the rise of the Communist Party and the German-American Bund, fight against racism and antisemitism in America, stand up for racial, religious and ethnic minorities, call for the U.S. to let in as many Jewish refugees from Europe as possible, denounce Adolf Hitler in Germany and Benito Mussolini in Italy as madmen, call out Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy and Nationalist Japan’s aggression on the international stage, urge the United States to enter World War II to help the Allies, oppose the Anschluss, be disgusted by the Munich Agreement, be disgusted by the persecution of the Jews in Germany, and call for the United States to do a massive military buildup to prepare ourselves for the day we inevitably would have to join the war.
Let’s say I’m living in Hungary in the 1930s and 1940s. I would be a proud Hungarian, proudly wave the Hungarian flag, love traditional Hungarian folk music and folk dances, revere Hungarian nation heroes like Saint Stephen, John Hunyadi, Matthias Corvinus, Francis II, and Lajos Kossuth, enjoy traditional Hungarian dishes like Goulash, Chicken Paprikash, Fisherman’s Soup, and Pörkölt, be a pious member of the Catholic Church, visit Budapest with great reverence and awe, help poor, unemployed and sick Hungarians during the Great Depression, and be furious about the Treaty of Trianon which took away two-thirds of Hungary’s land. At the same time, I would oppose the regime of Admiral Miklós Horthy, oppose Hungary trading with Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy, oppose the anti-Jewish laws passed by the government, be appalled by the discrimination faced by my Jewish neighbors, oppose Hungary joining the Axis Powers, oppose Hungarian troops being sent to assist Nazi Germany on the Eastern Front, oppose the Holocaust in Hungary, assist Hungarian Jews in escaping to safety, would fight against the German occupation of my country, oppose the puppet regime of Ferenc Szálasi and the Arrow Cross Party, protest the Soviet occupation, and would fight for a liberal democracy in Hungary.
Let’s say I’m living in Greece in the 1930s and 1940s. I would be a patriotic Greek, be proud of Ancient Greece and the fact that my country was the one that invented democracy, mathematics, theater, and the Olympic Games, wave the Greek flag with much pride, celebrate Independence Day, admire Alexander the Great’s conquests, admire Aristotle, Archimedes, Socrates, Plato, Pericles, Herodotus, Theódoros Kolokotrónis, and Georgios Karaiskakis, would love eating Moussaka, Gyros, Greek Salad, and Baklavas, love attending big Greek weddings, and would enjoy dancing the Kalamatianos. At the same time, I would be sad to see the fall of the Second Hellenic Republic, oppose the rule of King George II and Ioannis Metaxas, join the resistance movement and fight the Italian, German and Bulgarian invasions, oppose the Holocaust in Greece, help Greek Jews get out of the country, welcome the American, British and Commonwealth forces that liberated my country, and fight to restore democracy in my country after the war was over.