11 Comments
User's avatar
Steve's avatar

"None of this means Canada is Nazi Germany. But the comparison does not depend on identical political systems."

Is It Headed That Way?

Rod D. Martin's avatar

Writing in 1944, Hayek did a brilliant job in The Road to Serfdom of showing that all socialist systems -- whether Germany's, Britain's, or anyone else's -- tend in that direction.

Noah Otte's avatar

A tour de force and a clarion call for human rights by Alexander Muse! That you Dr. Martin for bringing it to our attention! RIP Sophia, Alan Nichols and all those talked into having their lives terminated unnecessarily! May their memory be a blessing! 🌸🌺💐🕊️🕯️This is Mark Carney’s Canada folks! Where are ever increasing number of people can have the government put them to death rather than actually help them. Moral paragdim Justin Trudeau apparently had no problem with this either. Never mind he was unbelievably corrupt, wore blackface and brownface, tried to freeze the bank accounts of people he didn’t agree with politically, called a Jewish MP a Nazi, parroted Hamas narratives during the Gaza War, and shoved a female MP when she was in his way rather than just saying “excuse me” like any normal, decent human being would.

Carney’s a real piece of work as well. He’s a ex-Governor of the Bank of Canada who couldn’t be more elitist if he tried. He bashes President Trump and then turns around and kisses up to him whenever he’s trying to secure a trade deal. On his watch, the Canadian economy has gone into a death spiral. Federal spending has skyrocketed on Carney’s watch as well. He continues to stick arbitrary and unnecessary regulations on fossil fuels. Not to mention that boondoggle of a pipeline he wishes to build which won’t work and will p*** off the First Nations people. Returning to the main subject of the piece, I am all for legalizing physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia. But ONLY for those who are in great pain, sound of mind and suffering from a terminal illness. Poverty, disability, having PTSD or Clinical Depression, etc. are NOT reasons to make someone eligible for state-sanctioned termination of life! Canada’s euthanasia program is beginning to look a lot like the Nazi’s T4 program. This is NOT how how Canada should be handling this program!

This is not compassionate or merciful! It is cruel and monstrous! Sophia and Alan Nichols were murdered by the state in secret and their families were not notified until after they had died. Roger Foley luckily said no. The state callously considered it cheaper to just kill them and be done with it than give them the help they needed. This is indefensible! I call on the United States to champion a resolution at the UN condemning Canada’s euthanasia program! The EU should also pass a resolution condemning it! Mark Carney should be forced to resign from office. Parliament most move immediately to pass a bill with broad cross party support, to limit those eligible for euthanasia to those who meet the above criteria I mentioned. Sophia and Alan Nichols’ families will receive an official apology from the Canadian government and be paid reparations. The doctors who performed their procedures will have their licenses revoked, will be arrested and charged with first-degree murder. Palliative medicine will be greatly expanded. Disability support will be improved.

Richard Amerling, MD's avatar

Once a society moves away from embracing the sanctity of life and towards concepts of a "life not worth living," or "useless eaters," the slippery slope is inevitable. Abortion is framed as saving the life of the mother (which is almost never the case), then expanded to "on demand" for any reason.

A medical profession that accepts, and even endorses, the intentional taking of innocent lives has completely abandoned any semblance of ethics. The comparison with Nazi doctors is justified, especially after witnessing the Covid debacle.

https://aapsonline.org/the-nazification-of-american-medicine/

Rod D. Martin's avatar

Yes, and even in relatively good systems, the minute you give the people who have legal power over life and death a cost incentive to prefer the latter, you're toast. This is precisely why socialized medicine is always a bad idea. If you want government to pay for healthcare, you need a voucher system: you must not have direct control.

Richard Amerling, MD's avatar

Exactly right. Direct third party payments to physicians interfere with the doctor-patient relationship and are inherently unethical. Patients need to understand this and move to third party-free practices, which are growing in number.

Steve's avatar

That Hideous Strength C.S Lewis

“Have you ever noticed,” said Dimble, “that the universe, and every little bit of the universe, is always hardening and narrowing and coming to a point?”His wife waited as those wait who know by long experience the mental processes of the person who is talking to them.“I mean this,” said Dimble in answer to the question she had not asked. “If you dip into any college, or school, or parish, or family — anything you like — at a given point in its history, you always find that there was a time before that point when there was more elbow room and contrasts weren’t quite so sharp; and that there’s going to be a time after that point when there is even less room for indecision and choices are even more momentous. Good is always getting better and bad is always getting worse: the possibilities of even apparent neutrality are always diminishing. The whole thing is sorting itself out all the time, coming to a point, getting sharper and harder.

Rod D. Martin's avatar

Fantastic book. I just re-read it a year ago.

Steve's avatar

FYI Free (my favorite price) On Youtube

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N0E3htddO_s

Couple of years ago I discovered Free Audio books on Youtube.

Darwin's avatar

Canada. Think about that. Canada. Who'd have imagined the depths of depravity mankind would fall to, particularly IN CANADA?! I hope/pray Canadians roust their wicked rulers sooner rather than later. And, punish them. We have problems with equal justice right now. The Leftists in the U.S. hijacked the judiciary while we were sleeping. Entire states have become enclaves of graft, murderous crime, and cheat the entire country. They're cancerous to our entire country. So, good luck!

Buddy S.'s avatar

Anyone even consider Hospice Care as assisted suicide?