The Rod Martin Report

The Rod Martin Report

Share this post

The Rod Martin Report
The Rod Martin Report
Pessimism in Historical Perspective
Geopolitics, Tech & Markets

Pessimism in Historical Perspective

As new breakthroughs continue to occur practically every day, looking back at how people decried and fought against progress in the past helps put current technological debates in perspective.

Guest Author
Dec 31, 2016
∙ Paid

Share this post

The Rod Martin Report
The Rod Martin Report
Pessimism in Historical Perspective
Share

by Chelsea German
December 31, 2016

Pessimism about potentially life-enhancing technologies is not new. The Twitter account Pessimist’s Archive (a favorite of the internet guru Marc Andreessen) chronicles the unending stream of pessimism with old newspaper excerpts.

Pessimistic reactions range from merely doubtful (such as this response to the idea of gas lighting in 1809, or this one to the concept of anesthesia in 1839) to outright alarmist (such as this 1999 warning that e-commerce “threatens to destroy more than it could ever create”).

In some cases, the pessimists insist that an older technology is superior to a new one. Some, for example, claimed that an abacus is superior to a computer and a pocket calculator, while others claimed that horses are longer-lasting than the dangerous “automobile terror.”

Others argue that new technology is damaging existing businesses and customs. One particularly emotional 1918 article described how automobiles are destroying the livery stable business…

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
A guest post by
Guest Author
© 2025 Rod D. Martin
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share